Dear Readers,
Yesterday was the record date for demerger of Orient Paper and Orient Electric. The stock was suggested on 29 July, 2017 at 96. Stock corrected to 85 on 10 August, 2017 and touched life time high 181 on 10 January, 2018. the reason behind mentioning these dates and price details because several readers are having intention to buy the Orient Paper at cmp 50 - 55. We have received lot of comments from last 2 -3 days related to demerger, listing date, buying price, selling price, future prospectus of paper business etc.
Answers for Common Questions
Need to keep the both stocks ( Orient Paper + Orient Electric) for further gain in long term. Both companies are having very good growth potential. Those investors who are holding the stock ( Orient Paper and Industries ) till 12.01.2018 in their demat accounts are eligible to get Orient Electric shares.
It is not advisable to buy Orient Paper at cmp. It is not advisable to buy any stock + / - 10 % from suggested price. If price is above that range then need to wait for correction or go for next stock. If price is below that range than I will give update on it, if required ( as given for Surana Solar in July 2017).
Generally demerger process is taking 12 -18 months time from date of proposal to the final listing. We have picked the stocks at mid of the process and Orient Electric is expected to list within next 4 months. We are keeping one stock with ongoing demerger process so that it will help to improve habit of holding the stock with patience for longer period.
If allocation is near 20% or above then partial profit can be booked near 100% to make the remaining holding free of cost and reinvestment to expand the portfolio without adding fresh fund. Profit can be booked at any time from 100% - 500% or above based on your holding capacity and financial needs.
Our investment in all stocks are for long term and irrespective of weak or good quarterly results. If there is any serious change in fundamental or future business prospectus of the company then only we will review and alter our investment decision.
Next stock will be posted in the last week of this month, most probably on 27 January.
Thanx madam for the update on orient paper. Eagerly waiting for your next recommendation...
ReplyDeleteMan, yours views on butterfly gandhimathi appliances, can this stock can be added @cmp??
ReplyDeleteIt is good stock but not advisable to buy at cmp
DeleteThanks for the info
ReplyDeleteMam I would like to know about butterfly gandhimathy...it's gud for investment @ current level???
ReplyDeleteNot advisable to buy at cmp
DeleteThanx mam! Please reply to the email
ReplyDeleteUnable reply emails since last 3 months due to lack of time. I will try to reply it in coming months.
DeleteHello Madam,
ReplyDeleteThanks for the update on Orient Paper.I started trading from end of last year only.After following your blog,I picked up Deepak Nitrite at price of 270.But you have mentioned +/-10% only.Please give your thought on whether to keep it or sell.Thank your
Now you can continue to hold as it is and try to buy near suggested price in future.
DeleteThank you so much mam for the update...God bless...
ReplyDeleteMam
ReplyDeleteExpected listing price of Orient electric.
We have not estimated the stock price during demerger and while listing because it will fluctuate for few weeks due to short term gain speculation done by traders / punters.
DeleteAfter few months stock price will stabilize according to valuation given by market (investors) and we expect around 100% return in one year and 300% in 4 years on initial investment.
https://dolly-bestpicks.blogspot.com/2017/07/orient-paper-industries-switch-to-smart.html
Dear Mam,
ReplyDelete1) Why the stock price dropped to 52 rupees from 170? I was expecting it to drop to around 85 rupees.
2) What would be the cost price for Orient Paper if we bought Orient Paper & Industries at 100 rupees? .. Will it be 50 rupees?
What is the cost price of of Orient Electric if we bought Orient Paper & Industries at 100 rupees? Will it be 50 rupees?
3) I am aware that price of resulting company (Orient Electric) is decided by market forces on listing date. At what price approximately will Orient Electric get listed according to you? I am expecting it to list above 120.
4) How much time will it take to list Orient e\Electric? As per my previous experience, it may take 6-9 months.
5) Have we lost liquidity of money in Orient Electric till it gets listed?
We have not estimated the stock price during demerger and while listing because it will fluctuate for few weeks due to short term gain speculation done by traders / punters. After few months stock price will stabilize according to valuation given by market (investors).
DeleteNo point of losing liquidity of money because stock is not suggested for few weeks
We expect around 100% return in one year and 300% in 4 years on initial investment.
Better to read the blog and comments for more clarity
https://dolly-bestpicks.blogspot.com/2017/07/orient-paper-industries-switch-to-smart.html
Thanks Mam
ReplyDeleteHello mam....shoud i buy at balasore nd banswara syntex and manasiaka coted....??plz advise ..nd hold alkali metal ??i hold arrond last 1.5 year...no huge return...so.plzz ..advise.
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking any of the above mentioned stocks.
DeleteNeed to keep the expectation reasonable because 90% return from Alkali Metal in 1.5 years is not small gain, you can continue to hold Alkali metal for further gain in next 2-3 years.
All stocks cannot give same return at same time but we expect sooner or later good return from all stocks.
Hello Mam, As Orient paper fall from 171 to 52, is it good buy now?
ReplyDeleteIt is not advisable to buy Orient Paper at cmp. You can buy next stock, it will be posted in the last week of this month, most probably on 27 January.
DeleteThanks Mam for update.Mam any view on Basant agro,Shiva Global Agro industries & Bharat Agri Fert & realty?
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking any of the above mentioned stocks.
DeleteDear Mam,Can you pls suggest good stock to buy before budget
ReplyDeleteSure
DeleteMam i hold Vadilal Industries@ 826 rupees. Should I keep holding it?
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it
DeleteThank you madam. What is the best price to buy Orient Paper in case if it goes down? Will it be okay to purchase below Rs. 40? and What about Orient electrical s?
ReplyDeleteOrient Paper + Orient Electric = 96
DeleteYou can buy + / - 10 % from suggested price ( 86 to 106 )
Thank You so much !!
DeleteDear Madam,
ReplyDeleteI have Omkar + Laza 1,400 each at suggested price. should I buy the right issue of Lasa? Do you have any price recommendation to buy right issue of Lasa? Or you will update at the time of right issue?
I will give update once right issue offer price announced
DeleteMrs Dolly,
ReplyDeleteWhat are your views regarding Goa Carbon? It has run up a lot since last year but it seems it does have steam left due to the demand supply tightness of Carbon black due to curtailment in China's production of the same and an upsurge in demand at the same time.
M'am is the next stock likely to be suggested on 27 Jan also likely to have the same future prospects as Deepak Nitrite both in the long term and short term?
Thanks and warm regards!
Navraj Grewal
Sorry not tracking Goa Carbon
DeleteYes, next stock will have also good growth potential both in the long term and short term
Maam Request your views on C G Power, GMR Infrastructure and India Steel Works Ltd
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking any of the above mentioned stocks including 3i Infotech
DeleteMam happy bogi sankranthi kanuma wishes god gives you tones of happiness
ReplyDeleteWishing very happy Makar Sankranti to you and your family
DeleteHappy pongal mam.
ReplyDeleteWishing very happy Pongal to you and your family
DeleteThank you so much Ma'am...God bless
ReplyDeleteRaised import duty on steel by 2.5%. Import duty on flat steel increased to
ReplyDelete10% from 7.5% and that on long steel products raised to 7.5% from 5%.
Further hiked import duty on Rat steel from 10% ta 12.5%.
Imposed provisional safeguard duty of 20% for 200 days on imported HRC.
Banned sale and import of any steel product that does not meet the Bureau I
of Indian Standards' (BIS) approval.
Imposed Minimum Import Pnce (MIP) on 1 73 steel products for slx months.
Extended steel safeguard duty unbl Mar-18 wRh a tapping structure.
Proposed provisional anti-dumping (AD) duties on HRC and CRC from China
South Korea, Japan, Indonesia and Brazil. Anti-dumping inves.tigattons were
underlay on wire rods and colour-coated products.
Extended MIP but only by two months and reduced the list of steel items
under MIP to 66 from 173 earlier. However, most of the HRC/CRC products
were covered by anti.dumping duties.
Imposed safeguard duty of 1 0% on import of hot rolled nat sheets and plates
(excluding hot rolled flat products in coll foml) of alloy or non-alloy steel up
to Nov-2017. The duty will be gradually reduced to 696 by FY19.
Extended MIP by two months but reduced the list of steel items under MIP to
19 from 66 earlier. However, most of the coated and wire rod products were
already covered by anti-dumping duties now.
Concluded final anti-dumping investigations on HRC and CRC steel and
recommended imposition of definRive anti-dumping duties an these
products.
Notified anti-dumping duties on HRC steel ohginating in, or exported from
China, Japan, Korea, Russia, Brazil or Indonesia for a period of 5 years
staring Aug-2016.
Notified anti-dumping duties on CRC steel onqlnatinq in, or exported from china, japan, korea or ukraine for a prriod of 5 years.
These steps were taken from june 2015 to may 2017. So do you feel there can be any stock which can be suggested as multi- bagger returns which is trading well below its fairvalue like kamdhenu ltd
Yes it is very good step taken by government to revive the debt ridden steel sector
Deleteare u tracing Himadri Speciality Chemical and akash optic fibre ?
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking any of the above mentioned stocks
Deletemadam view about balmerlawri n viceroy hotels
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking any of the stocks mentioned by you. It is not advisable to buy Donear at CMP
DeleteYou can buy next stock it is very good investment option.
Hello mam @ what price we can buy butterfly gandhimathy home appliance once it's coming buying range??? Whether it's a gud multibagger
ReplyDeleteI have already replied above to your comment.
DeleteOnce I will say it is good stock to buy below 200 then you will ask, are you expecting correction?
It already moved from 200 to 600 within a few months so no point to chase it at CMP.
Dear friends see the last 3 years madam recommendation stocks.abnormal returns.why asking again and again unnecessary questions, about gandhimathy madam answered many times.pl this is my request to all
DeleteRequest readers to exercise self retrain and not ask stupid and irrelevent repetitive question and help ourselves to take maximum benefits of Dolly Khanna ma;am advise,else BLOCK system may be activated.Please cooperate.
DeleteI appeal to all blog users to please use this blog wisely and restrain yourself from asking repeated and irrelevant questions.
DeleteSorry mam,
DeleteDear Syam,
DeleteNo need to take the above comments personally, even though we know that several stocks may give further gain but we never encourage to buy these stocks due to heavy risk exist after buying at higher price. Same Butterfly Gandhimathi I used to hold in 2010 -12 and it was trading near 400 then it corrected and remain below 200 for more than 2 years till October 2017.
In the stock market if we able to save our principal investment amount then we will get good gain for sure due to this reason I always prefer to suggest safe stock at safe buying price. I can take risk with my money but I cannot take any risk with your money or thousands of our blog readers.
Heart touching reply...I can take risk with my money but I can't take any risk with your or thousands of our blog readers. Such and Good Soul May God give you Good Health Ma'am. I am also new and waiting for next Stock idea to come.
DeletePranam.
Regds,
Sujeet
Excellent and very much satisfying explanation about your personal holdings, Madam.Blog readers, please try to understand that the risk level differs from person to person and also increases with entry price.Please try to avoid questions about Madams personal holdings just because it is known to all because of SEBI's Share Holding Pattern disclosures.Madam is guiding us by giving 7/8 Multibaggers which may give at least 36% CAGR which is well above banks FD interest rate and inflation.So please try to increase your wealth with the help of Madams blog recommendeded stocks.
DeleteIt is being said that there is no free lunch in the world.But by Gods grace Madam is providing free recommendations. So blog readers, please DO NOT ask questions regarding personal holdings of Madam which may create unnecessary issues .There are certain norms imposed by SEBI about sharing of stock ideas in public forums.So please cooperate, blog readers.
DeleteGreat Madam. I have seen many blogs who give their recommendation. But not like you.
DeleteYou are a big name in India Stock Market and you spend so much time for retail investors.. Also you answer everybody questions. When you felt somebody might have felt bad by other commenst, you are still keeping your patience level and help him understand in more detailed manner.. Awesome! Wishing u and ur family a good health and happiness.. Happy Makara Sankaranthi
Mam, amazed to see your dedication to small retail investors. i am starting with 3L cash. no holding as of now. please suggest.
ReplyDelete1. how much allocation to give in your upcoming stock out of 3lac
2. what to do with rest amount for the time being till u announce next stock. To keep cash , or some temporary stock.
thank u for guidance mam.
You can Allocate 20% in next stock. Keep the remaining cash ready in case of market correction you can add Sintex plastic below 80.
DeleteHappy Pongal to you and your family madam and all blog members who are all celebrating in different names.
ReplyDeleteWishing very happy Pongal to you and your family
DeleteHappy Lohri & Makar Sankranti to you and your family Mam
ReplyDeleteWishing very happy Lohri, Makar Sankranti & Pongal to you and your family
DeleteWhy few blog members dont understand a simple thing : Buy strictly within "10% of the suggested price". If u could not for some reasons then just wait for next recomendation. If u still wish to buy something after it has already given a 20 30% return and you still believe in mam's assesment then just buy at your own will and keep your return expectation a bit less. Dont panic always when a stock give a good runup and you miss it. Wait , more opportunities will come your way . Mam is there
ReplyDeleteYes you are absolutely right because this blog is open forum if we start giving different targets, different buying prices for same stock to different readers then several investors will get confused and finally end up with wrong decision.
DeleteHappy bhogi and makes sankranthi to you and your family mam
ReplyDeleteWishing very happy Makar Sankranti to you and your family
DeleteMadam,
ReplyDeleteMy target is 1 crore by 2021-22
Started inv in your reco. Since pennar. I am moving all my earlier inv in mutual funds gradually to your reco stocks.
Pls suggest me a strategy next.
I like to inv a lakh each in ur all comming reco.
Will it be enough?
Please reply.
God bless you and you keep blessing us.
Thank you
Yes it will be more than enough till end of 2022
DeleteMadam, 1 more doubt sorry
DeleteI hv invested only 3lakhs till now in 6 recommendation. I am trying to invest 7-8 lakhs in 2018 . so total would be 11 lakhs by end of 2018. Where do you see this 11 lakhs in dec 2021.
Then in 2019 i may only be able to spare 4 lakhs for your reco. Where do you see those 4 lakhs in dec 2021.
If you able to invest near to suggested price and able to compound your money at the rate of average yearly return of blog suggested stocks then you can achieve your target in maximum 8.5 years with 11 lakh investment . It means stocks need to buy at right price at right time and profit also need to be booked at right time and the principal amount need to reinvest again and again , keep the free of cost share for long-term
DeletePerfect..Thank you madam. With you around the future looks brighter.
DeleteHappy sankranthi madam.
ReplyDeleteWhat is the best price to buy orientation papers ..
Is it right time to buy???
We are eagerly expecting new updates from you madam.
Wishing very happy Makar Sankranti to you and your family
DeleteIt is not right time to buy orient paper.If it is must buy for you then you can buy it near 25 in case of further correction.
Wishing you and your family a happy Makar sankranti. God bless you.
ReplyDeleteWishing very happy Makar Sankranti to you and your family
DeleteMadam sorry for asking a trivial query. I booked a short term loss by selling Orient on the 11th Jan @ Rs53 and bought again on 12th
ReplyDeleteJan. Pl let me know the following :
1) Will I eligible for Orient Electric Shares?
2) Can I offset this Short Term loss with short term gain already booked ?
The record date for Orient was 12th Jan
Thanks in anticipation and sincere regards
You are not eligible to get orient electric shares. You can continue to hold the shares as it is because need to stick with own investment decision. sometime loss can give better experience than profit
DeleteDear Dollyji,
DeleteGood evening,
I will to make small clarification in case of rajat. I think, Rajat has sold the shares of orient paper on 11th Jan 2018 to book short term loss, which was purchased by him on earlier date. Since 11th jan, 2018 is the ex date for Spin off, he will be eligible for shares of Orient Electric. As per my knowledge, if anybody sell shares on ex-date, he is always entitled for the purpose for which such ex-date is announced.
This is submitted for your kind perusal to clarify him on the subject.
Thanks & Best Regards,
Rajat is not saying when he bought the shares which he sold on 11 Jan, he may have bought in the morning and sold in the evening. If he has bought near suggest price in July than this question will never come.
DeleteHello mam, All of stock recommendations on this blog are profitable.
ReplyDeleteEven as per suggestions I am holding surana solar as 5% of portfolio. That too on track to move. So NO PROBLEM at all.
Rest of all are in excellent profits. You are BEST GUIDE for stock market.
About learning experience of PATIENCE I want to share that...Initially I bought KESORAM at 150 and then accumulated around 128. Now it's around 20% holding with good profit.
Holding Long all stocks.
Thanks a Lot. God Bless You and Be with Us Forever.
.Hello Mam,
ReplyDeleteAfter this demerger, how the assets will be distributed will it be any one company or divided equally among the two. as they have huge equity assets and land parcels
Assets distribution is according to the proposed scheme of demerger
DeleteHi dollyji, thanks for all ur guidance , I am following ur blog since september 2017, and have purchased orient paper and deepak nitrate at the price that u had recomended, thanks a lot. God bless you .I was interested in dredging corporation and LT foods but need ur advice.
ReplyDeleteDredging Corporation and LT food are good stock for long-term investment but the recently both stocks moved up significantly so it is not advisable to buy at CMP. You can buy these stocks in case of correction up to 25-30%
DeleteHello Madam...
ReplyDeleteWhat would be the correct price of Orient Electric?
Orient paper + Orient electric = 96 is correct price for both
DeleteAfter listing we will know that the exact price people want to pay for orient electric
Happy makar sankranti to you and your family mam..god bless you always..stay bless and happy always....
ReplyDeleteWish you very happy Makar Sankranti
DeleteIs it ok to buy surana solar at curr levels
ReplyDeleteYes you can buy it if you have read the update posted in the month of July 2017 on Sarana solar and willing to hold without expecting any profit till 2022
Deletemam your thoughts on Lakshmi energy and foods ltd?
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDear All, This was raised by one of the blog member earlier also. I don't think Dolly ji has any time to do that in addition to the time she is spending on this blog and research etc. She has already mentioned few times that from last 3 months she is unable to reply to our emails due to the time restrain. I have learnt a lot in last 2years plus from this blog. It's priceless and I don't think we can pay any price or appreciate enough for what Dolly ji does. If we want to learn more then our questions should be asked accordingly rather than asking common sense and repetitive question. I know It's easier to ask questions as they don't cost anything. I wonder how many people will ask same questions if we were to pay. Rather than reading a book on investment and getting lessons, please try to read the whole blog carefully and make your own notes and see what has been the result. It's practical experience where you learn, understand, invest, hold investment while it is going through ups and down and witness progress/results. My humble request is to spend some serious time in going through the whole blog prior to asking any question. We have to take some decisions ourselves whether right or wrong. At least we have taken some decision and hopefully we will learn a lot from that decision.
DeleteI apologise, if I have said too much. I was just expressing my thoughts in the interest of making this blog more effective, efficient and interesting.
Happy investing and kind regards,
Param
Dear co_ reader, how much u can pay for this ? Pl pay respect & not to measure everything with money.when u getting tonnes of good stocks without paying money it is worthless,but some ones getting worst stock ideas by paying money.pl think before saying anything.Mother nurries child not to think what she will get returned in future. Thousands of investors in India ,lacks in the whole world they may be Triliowner,they have spotted tonnes of successful stocks by buying stocks or selling stock idea but nobody in the whole world can't think simple way to help such us novice & worthless investors, Football with Maradona,song through Kishore Kumar, painting of van Gogh all they're born with their inborn talents.so, brother don't try to find egg but it will be better to eat boiled egg.A blog she is maintaining for 3 years, day by day answering so many repeated & worthless questions even some time I feel anger but think about her love like my mother.so, please request you not to write such kind of words in future,please.
DeleteThis is not a paid service.... maam is doing for sake of all the individuals who are following her...continuous experience with the blog suggested stocks will give you much needed stock picking abilities..just follow that
DeleteWats ur expectetion of nocil result?
ReplyDeleteResult is good you can continue to hold it for further again but not advisable to buy at CMP
DeleteSorry for repeating my query. Just wanted to understand for future reference. If I sold Orient on 11th Jan @ 53(adjusted price) NOT at around 180 which was the price before 11th. Now since we folliw (T+2) settlement, shares would still be there in my demat account on 12th Jan.By the same logic then ,if I bought the shares on 12th Jan @53 whether the seller or myself would be eligible for Orient Electric shares? Pl correct me so that I dont commit any mistake in future.Regards
ReplyDeleteIf you have bought Orient paper shares on or before 10 January then only you are eligible to get orient electric shares.
DeleteOh I just received the followingsg from NSDL :"Orient Paper 400 shares debited to your account on 15th Jan".Pl elaborate.Thanks so much
ReplyDeleteYes it will appear in your demat account but get allocated for trading only once the orient electric will be listed on stock exchanges
DeleteMam and sir
ReplyDeleteWishing you happy ponhal and your blog is more than any businees chaneel and y tube channels for thr small investers like us. Thanks a lot.
Wishing very happy Pongal to you and your family
DeleteThank you so much for your guidance mam....Wishing you and your family a very happy Makar Sankranti....God bless...
ReplyDeleteWishing very happy Makar Sankranti to you and your family
DeleteHello Dolly ji,
ReplyDeletePondy Oxide. I have already recovered my cost by selling some shares at various prices and now remaining quantity is free of cost. Should I sell remaining quantity also to raise funds to invest in the new stock. I don't have any fresh funds to invest. Other question is both Kamdhenu and Pondy are at more than 500% gain. Is it better to sell Pondy as Kamdhenu has much more potential. Many thanks for your guidance.
You can continue to reinvest your principal amount and keep the free of cost shares for further gain in both Pondy oxide and Kamdhenu.
DeleteHello Mam, By when would we get Orient Electric shares in our demat account
ReplyDeleteIt will appear in your demat account within 30 days but it will be ready for trading near to the listing of orient electric on stock exchanges
DeleteHi Madam,
ReplyDeleteAre there any fundamental changes in TCI and TCIEXP. Since past 6 months both have not moved up with market trend. Infact TCI has gone down by 11%.
Thanks,
Arun
You can continue to hold both stock for decent gain in next 2 - 3 years. Fundamentals are best in industry for both stocks in their respective segments
DeleteMaam,
ReplyDeleteThank you for the update on Orient Paper Industries.
Could you please point me to any communication issued by the company on how to calculate cost of acquisition of shares of both companies (Orient Paper and Orient Electric) post-demerger?
Thank you for your selfless service.
You can read the full documents of demerger scheme to get all information. it is available on the company website.
DeleteMam, I have purchased orient paper @ 170 on 10th jan, Will i be eligible for orient electric shares.
ReplyDeleteYes you are eligible to get orient electric shares.
DeleteDear madam,
ReplyDeleteHappy sankranthi to you and your family.!!
Can I buy KCP Ltd & GATI Ltd at CMP.
Very happy Makar Sankranti to you and your family
DeleteIt is not advisable to buy any of the above mentioned stocks at CMP
OSCL have planned board meeting on February 5 for both the quarters
ReplyDeleteMam do see a strong market correction lingering somewhere near?
ReplyDeleteSome market correction is normal after major rally
Deletehi Mam,
ReplyDeleteCan you please throw some light on LASA supergenics such as What is the right issue price, what is the ratio and what is the dead line to apply for rights issue. I tried to find these details from BSE site, but i couldnt find these details .
Still nothing is finalised, company will give give update on it
DeleteMam I am hilding kcp with avg cost. Rs 120. Shall I hold this for target of 300?
ReplyDeleteAny idea about 3i infotech ? I have with avg price of 6.
No change in previous view for KCP, we can expect around 300% return in four years
DeleteNot tracking other stock
Mam what is your review on amtek auto
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it
DeleteHi Dolly, Wish you and your family a very happy Makar Sankranti..
ReplyDeleteThis is my first query on your blog and I hope it gets answered. I have bought pennar inds and sintex plastics at 76 and 93 respectively. I am looking for 10-15% return . How long do I need to hold these scripts ? Whats your recommendation ?
Now you can continue to hold both stocks for next 3 - 4 years for much better return than your expectation.
DeleteIt is not advisable to buy the stocks at high price with 10 - 15% expectation.
Thanks for your inputs. Looking forward to your new stock recommendation..
DeleteHow much return we can expect from Pennar Inds and Sintex Plastics in 3-4 years.
DeleteNo change in previous view for in Pennar industry it can you give around 300% return in four years from suggested price
DeleteWe can expect around 15% to 20% return in Sintex plastic
respected madamji query 1) regarding jk agri genetics my avg buying price 385 at cmp around 1750 since from here how much tgt we can see in next 3 yrs ? 5000 is it possible?? i can hold for next 5 yrs . 2) is there any chances of demerger story in technocraft industries . my buying price 190--since in the next 3 yrs how much tgt can we expect . please reply
ReplyDeleteIf allocation is more than 10% in JK agri then you can book some profit and keep the remaining quantity is for further gain in future. It is seasonal stock and it may correct below 1000 in case of few poor result during off season and same time it may also cross 3000 in no time with one or 2 good results.
DeleteTechnocraft has not achieved still 300% return level so you can continue to hold as it is
Before i knew your blog, due to lack of guidance and knowledge, i invested in Vama industries @30 and Arihant Capital @185. Since i bought those two i was always in loss. In case of any correction in market i may further loose my capital investment. Please suggest should i book loss in those stockss and invest in your upcoming stock suggestion.
ReplyDeleteI have been following your blog since last 2 months and reading your replies carefully and gaining lot of knowledge.
Mam thanks a lot for your sincere guidance. May god reward you the best you deserve for your work.
Sorry not tracking any of the above mentioned stocks, you can take the decision according to your past experience with these stocks. Always prefer to stick with your investment decision and give 2 to 3 years time to perform the stocks to know the actual progress of the company.
Deleterespected madamji, whats ur view regarding fairchem speciality chemicals--and clariant chemicals from cmp is there are any chance of multifold returns or how much we can expect returns . waiting reply
ReplyDeleteWe can expect around 15 to 20% return per year from Clairant chemicals but not tracking other stock.
DeleteMam I read in previous comments about sintex plastic to buy at 80 or below 80 level .. can sintex plastic has potential to give 100 to 300 cent for the time period of 1 to 3 years...regards mam and thanks in advance for your valuable and important guidance...
ReplyDeleteExpected return around 15 to 20% per year
DeleteMa'am Happy Makarsankranti
ReplyDelete1.I think we should read the earlier comments on blog by Madam before asking anything in order to avoid repeat questions. It's sheer waste of time for Madam and all of those who read everything in the blog, she is already devoting lot of time and efforts for betterment of small investors. 2. Questions should be related to investing philosophy so as to learn the trick. 3 Questions should be mainly regarding the recommended stocks, so as to remain focused on only these stocks giving returns (many times) about 100% in a year and 300-400% in four five years. Why should we look beyond these stocks? Many other good stocks which followers ask about, give 10-20 % return which is way bellow recommended stocks. 4. Focused & concentrated folio is Madam's preferred way to create wealth and we should not divert away from it. 5.She is one of the most respected, successful stock pickers in Indian markets, we must stick to her advice wholeheartedly in our own interest. Thank you mam for your love, affection for novice investors and splendid efforts to help, educate them
ReplyDeleteDear Mam,
ReplyDeleteI am a beginner in stock analysis. Is it good to buy Maithan Alloys Ltd at current price of 945 rupees ? Maitan has P/E 9.32 and I have read that stocks with less than 10 P/E is good to buy (but this alone is not a good parameter).
What is your opinion on Maithan ?
Sorry not tracking it
DeleteThanks for ur reply.mam.. early i bought 8000 shares of nocil.. 95 per share.. i got lot of profit mam.. thank u very much..
ReplyDeleteMadam good that u have given update on orient paper, but what about the fate of chemfab alkalis almost 10 months since stopped trading.pls update on this stock because if stocks take so long to list then we are losing our liquidity
ReplyDeleteYes it got a little bit delay but the listing will happen only once the company will get permission from stock exchanges. No other option just need to wait with patience till listing.
DeleteMam what is review on aarvee denim
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it
Deletemam as u said to achieve goal we need to buy at 1. right price . 2. stick to investment decisions for 2 to 3 years. 3. book profits from time to time.
ReplyDeletei have a doubt on 3rd point. when to know its the right time to book profit in a certain stock.
Book profit from 100% and above at any time according to you are holding capacity and financial needs
DeleteMam,
ReplyDeleteIs Pokarna@240/- good for long term ?
Sorry not tracking it
DeleteMam, I am averaging out on Nocil @153. Is it still better to accumulate and what would be a better average for the stock? What is the level of appreciation I can expect if I hold it for 3 years? Thanks.
ReplyDeleteIt is not advisable to buy at CMP. It was a good stock to buy near 50 but you are accumulating at 200, it is good time to start booking some profit
DeleteMam,is it advisable to invest in Kesoram at cmp?
ReplyDeleteIt is not advisable to buy at CMP
DeleteMadam
ReplyDeleteThere is an article in money control
about sintex plastics that repairing the balance sheet.article on yesterday.it means it takes time to recover business or wait for some time?
Your views pls mam.
Thanx
It can be bought below 80 with expected return around 15 to 20% per year
DeleteDear Dolly ma'am,I got to read your blog a month back by chance and was highly impressed.Could buy a small amount in Deepak Nitrite.As I have some liquidity,just starting investing,and if market correct and some of your recommended stock comes under recommended buying range, in what priority you would recommend buying, stock wise(only possibility of 2017 recommendation-ADF Foods,Pennar,KPC,Kesoram OrientPaper-already split,Gati,Deepak) beside new stock coming on 27 Jan.It will help me to invest if market correct and I get an opportunity.Million thanks.You indeed is a gem.
ReplyDeleteIf you get the chance to buy within 10% from suggested price then you can add otherwise you can wait till 27 January for next stock
DeleteMam as u suggested to add some sintax plastics below 80 2 days back. how much allocation to give to adding sintax plastic out of 3L fresh investment
ReplyDeleteYou can give the location 10 to 20% but keep the expectation of 15 to 20% return per year only. It is not a blog suggested stock but I have replied to the comments to the people who are interested to buy it or already hold it
DeleteHello mam I have radico, rain industries, prakash constrowell and morpen lab all these shares are giving me 100 to 150% return. Which should I sale from these and which I should keep for long run. Pls advise
ReplyDeleteYou can book some profit in rain industry and keep the remaining for further gain.
DeleteNot tracking other stocks
Hello mam if possible could u plz analyse the result of federal bank??? I have some shares,should I exit or hold this scrip.plz help me to take a good decision.
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it,
DeleteIt is not advisable to buy the stock based on quarterly result
Man, ls there any anti-dumping imposed by India in acetone & phenol?
ReplyDeleteThere are very few manufacturers so no point to impose anti-dumping duty on it
DeleteDear Ma'am,
ReplyDeleteSome people are cautioning retail investors about recent rally in Midcap & smallcap and comparing them with highs of 2007. what is your view on this?
Thankyou
God bless you:)
Just check about these people whether they have sold their entire holding or just spreading the rumours. Ask their view about it
DeleteAs I understand, the low allocation has no meaningful role in portfolio for wealth creation. In percentage terms it needs to be 10-20%. Mam, what it would be like in actual terms i.e. What should be minimum amount to be meaningful allocation
ReplyDeleteIf your portfolio has given hundred percent return then 10% is okay, if you have taken 1000% written then 5% okay if you have taken 10,000% return then even one percent is okay
DeleteI didn't understand it. Will you explain it with a hypothetical example. It's very important for me to understand the concept of allocation. Thank you very much.
DeleteBetter to get the actual experience by keeping only five stock in your portfolio.
DeleteIf you have already five stock then sell all and by hundred stocks to get the actual experience
Madam if I have one lakh rupees to invest,how much % allocation should I have to give in this year's recommendations. If so with this one lakh when can I achieve 10 lakhs.
ReplyDeleteYou can allocate 20% or 20,000 in each stock in next five stocks. If you will not buy and sell shares on time then you may never achieve your target. Just read the blog and take action accordingly to achieve your target quickly, there is no fixed time but it completely depends upon your effort.
DeleteYou will have to compound at 26% CAGR to hit that goal in 10 years. You can go online and google CAGR calculator/compound interest calculator. This will give you some perspective with regards to the power of investing. 1 lakh compounded at 26% CAGR would be worth 10 lakhs in 10 years, 1cr in 20 years, 10cr in 30 years and 100cr in 40 years. Now you see the power? What if you compound only at 15 or 20% over a 40 year period you will still make a killing and leave your family not only millionaires in dollar terms, but multi millionaires! Every Indian should invest 1 lakh in MFs at the age of 20 and go on an sip throughout working life. They will retire very very rich and their kids could then take over the portfolio and never need to depend on a boss or a job again.
DeleteYour view on Kabra extrusion n Electrosteel Casting @ 36/-
ReplyDeleteRegards
Sorry not tracking it
DeleteMam any thoughts about Shivalik bimetals and Globus Spirits?
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking any of the above mentioned stocks
Delete
ReplyDeleteKarken Account
Orlandodsa
654321@olu
Hello Mam, trust your doing well
I’m holding a few stocks recommended by you like Kesoram,KCP, ABRFL and TCI which have all given me a decent return,
I am in a little loss with below stocks and holding them for over a year now
Tata motors DVR - baught 300 stocks @300
And Lupin 100@ 950
Shall I sell both of these to buy your next recommendation ? Or should I hold on to them and pump in more cash ?
Thankful of you could advise.
Sorry not tracking Tata motors DVR and Lupin. You may take the decision according to your past experience with these stocks
Deletemam i am planning to sell my unused apartment worth 1.2 cr. and insvest in blog suggested stocks and tips. do you think it will be a good idea? considering past returns it absolutely is but about future??
ReplyDeleteYou can sell your apartment if you are able to hold the stocks for long-term
DeleteOmkar promoter holding is 27% As the number of pledged shares is also too high, is it a cause for concern?
ReplyDeleteNo
DeleteHi Madam, do you track Deep Industries, NMDC, Karnataka Bank? Do you think its a good time to accumulate these stocks. Also, just wanted to know if its good to have cyclical stocks commodity stocks (eg - NMDC in this case) for long in the portfolio?
ReplyDeleteKarnataka bank is good stock to buy below 150 with expected return around 15 to 20% per year
DeleteNo tracking other stocks
Ma'am Ur views on oricon enterprise at cmp??
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it
DeleteHi mam just started reading ur blog few days bak a friend of mine recommended. I Hav a position in deepak nitrate wat r ur views on polson & sanwaria consumer
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking above mentioned stocks
DeleteHi,
ReplyDeleteWhat is your view on TinPlate a debt free Tata group company.....
Hello Mam,
ReplyDeleteI had read all your recommendations, followers comments and your reply on your blog.
I am a salaried person and also new in share market. From last 6 to 9 months after office hours collecting some information regarding share market. Now I have some basic information about market and want to built a portfolio for long term.
I have only salary income and wants to invest Rs. 10000/- each stock which will recommend by you onward.
So, How can I start? (means when to entered?, @ what time book profit and exit)
Waiting for your valuable reply.
Hello Dolly,
ReplyDeleteI want to invest around 40 Lacs in your recommendations. Could you please suggest 5 stocks I can invest into for good returns in 2-3 years. I missed your earlier recommendations.
My understanding is when we have Stocks suggested with 110-300%returns within 1-3 years time , then why to hop around with multiple questions which will give 15-20% annual returns ?? I feel at peace with the stocks suggested with +/- range and thoroughly researched links to support the reasons for suggestions .
ReplyDeleteMy last one year experience is overly satisfying , my gratitude to ma'am and all Informative answers . God Bless !
Greetings Madam,
ReplyDeleteThank you for your detailed update on demerger of Orient Papers. The help and guidance you are offering to retail investors like is simply amazing and I am grateful to you for the same.
Query: How many stocks will you be giving us this year; so that we can decide on allocation.
Thanks and Regards,
D. Viswambharan