Monday, December 21, 2015

Feedback for Improvement

Dear Readers, 



We are very near to complete the first anniversary of this blog. All of you have given your commendable contribution by posting valuable comments to create positive outlook for investment specially among the new investors. After analyzing the feedback from last one years on different issues, I need your suggestion to for better improvement on below points. 


1.   Is it required to modulate the comments on the blog? Without modulation all comments will be get posted either it is positive or negative or personal remark on someone. Some time I have  filtered  few comments with personal or negative remark.
   a)  Yes   
   b)  No        
   c)  Your suggestion if any      
 
2.   Is it required to post every month new stock suggestion? In 2015, total 9 stock suggestions were posted but now every month 10 -15 % new readers are joining us and they are looking for new stock suggestion instead of investing in old suggested stocks which are already appreciated more than 35 - 50%.                                                                                                                                                                      
   a)  Yes   
   b)  No        
   c)  Your suggestion if any      
 
3.   Is it required to give clue for new stock suggestion? In the past we have seen that some messages were posted on public web sites before publishing in the blog. But in the previous stock more than 40 readers are able buy it before publishing based on given clues and maintained the confidentiality.                                                                                                                    
   a)  Yes   
   b)  No        
   c)  Your suggestion if any  

4.   Is it better to post long or repeated comments with anonymous ID  or critical inquiries on my mail dolly1970.khanna@gmail.com ? Up to 250 comments per post can open normally after that it start hanging & it is taking time to load the comments.                                                                                                                                                                                                                     
   a)  Yes   
   b)  No        
   c)  Your suggestion if any         
   
 
5.   Is it required to change the outlook of the blog - like design, name, recent picture, font style ? Some of the readers have given suggestion for change.                                                                                                   
   a)  Yes   
   b)  No        
   c)  Your suggestion if any        
6.   Are you getting  really any benefit from this blog? It may be giving confidence, knowledge, guidance or financial benefit etc.                                                                                                                                 
   a)  Yes   
   b)  No        
   c)  Your suggestion if any         
Please give your true feedback on mail dolly1970.khanna@gmail.com 
You can also post it on this blog ( feedback related comment will not be published on blog) so that we can improve it accordingly.

You can reply  just by putting # 1 Yes, #2 No etc.

I will publish the feedback results in % by next week end (Saturday 26.12.2015).

162 comments:

  1. Dear madam,
    Suzloan buying back @18.. cmp 21 wht is ur view?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. High debt is only major concern, RE business is good

      Delete
  2. Thank u mam for your good and selfless work for innocent investors like me.pleas throw some light on venus remedies .you r holding since march qtr 2015.why its bottom line drastically came down.can i buy @ current price for 2 to 3yrs.thank u.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fresh entry not advisable until company start showing some good results.

      Delete
  3. I hv invested in dtil technocraft waterbase donnear ind and kothari chemical.now i want to add venus remedies after seeing that you are holding 135000 lac shares so i want to buy it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Better invest in next stock it can give much better return than Venus.

      Delete
  4. it has Provided good article for traders and investors in stock market.thanks for sharing ..

    ReplyDelete
  5. Maam your recommendations are fabulous

    ReplyDelete
  6. Dear Mam,

    Happy anniversary !! Congrats on 1 year!
    Wishing you many more years and looking forward to following along!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Sam, definitely I will reply if you will ask any personal question on mail.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Mam you are very good i bought donear at 19 2000 shares still iam holding thanks very much mam kothari i have 600 shares thanks so much

    ReplyDelete
  9. Hi Dolly,
    Appreciate your hardwork in helping with your valuable suggestions.. I would like to raise a concern, currently there is setting in this blog that says your comments will be posted after approval. I think this way we are not accepting any healthy negative comments.. It would be good if we remove approval process here...

    Last time, I have raised a concern which was not posted here. The question was this. When a fundamental analyst suggested stock Donear industries, it went 50% in a week time. I really don't understand why people buy it blindly with out analysis..

    I understand when there is a hot stock people rush to buy it. However, 50% run in a week time is not healthy.

    It would be great if you can comment on this scenario.


    Thanks,
    Ram

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Ram, I think you are right that a stock run up for 50% or more in a week is not healthy. In stock market, sentiments play a crucial role in stock price movements for short term only. But for long term, ultimately what matters in earnings. If you have patiency, most of these recommend stocks will correct as part of consolidation and you may get it cheaper. For example check the waterbase stock, it has moved to 52 weeks high of 176/- and corrected back to 110/- now and may go even lower based on the quarterly results.


      Regards,
      Venu.

      Delete
    2. Investors must do analysis before investing in any stocks and must verify the facts given in this blog. Price control is not in our hand market deciding how much people want to pay by seeing the value getting in return.

      Delete
  10. Your pattern of finding stocks is excellent n very helpful .. Thank u

    ReplyDelete
  11. Wishing u happy 1st anniversary n may such many yrs u keep up with ur work of helping investors

    ReplyDelete
  12. Mam, ur view on chembond chem and ashok alco-chem??

    ReplyDelete
  13. Thxs madam for your valuable suggestions .IHave invested without fear of loss after reading your blog

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thanks providing your valuable suggestions for Small investors like us

    ReplyDelete
  15. Hello madam,
    I invested heavily in Donear. It is up 25% in last 2 days I think because your recommendation has spread in market. Should I hold or sell?

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi, any new recommendation soon? Thanks !!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Dolly ji, indian terrain is trading at 160/- it is very near to 52 week low, is it suggestable to buy like donear, ple suggest me.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hi mam can i buy Donear now I missed it out completely pls advise
    Thanks
    Ragani

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You can buy next stock in Jan 1st wk. It has also huge potential even better than Donear.

      Delete
  19. First of all I want to thank you for puuting the effort so that others can make money.
    Mam my only suggestion is that you atleast give 2 or 3 days of notice before recommending a new stock so that we can liquidate our existing stocks and keep cash to invest in new stock.
    Thanks & God bless
    CA Prince Ninan

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hi,

    Is there any frequency of your current stock suggessions. For example, First saturday of everymonth, or second Friday of everymonth after market hours, etc... like that.

    Best Regards,
    Ravi

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It will be mostly on 1st friday after market hours so that most of the readers will get enough time to analyse it before buying.

      Delete
  21. heard that donear is placing shares at around 50+. Is it true they are raising funds.

    ReplyDelete
  22. still holding R S Software what to do.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Hi madam,
    Whats your view on "Karuturi Global Ltd". This is penny stock.Time frame(2-3 yrs)

    ReplyDelete
  24. Dear Mam, I have FUTURE RETAIL LIMITED DVR @ 93.. Is it good to hold or sell..

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hello Dolly Madam,
    Can you please give your valuable suggestion on Archidply Industries ?
    Thanks
    Nilesh Bhagwat

    ReplyDelete
  26. Res madam,
    Thanks for support and sharing stocks with us. Your conviction and analysis of stocks really grt. I found most of the your selected stocks are undervalued and below ( i chart)
    200 dma and after your buying stocks becoming bullish.madam u can addstocks I chart at what cmp u buy? It will be very gd for our blog. So new investor also know and also please add stocks filter criteria what u considered .so we will also improve.

    Madam ji please suggests next or upcoming script like
    eicher mortars or wipro.

    Regards drvivek patil

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Need to follow below steps

      1.Product and market demand is the main criteria. Once you will find
      what market need now and what it needs in next 2-3 years.

      2 shortlist the companies from above field with good fundamental.

      3 Invest in companies having capable and good promoters.

      Next stock is having huge potential, one of the best in its sector.

      Delete
  27. Hi mam, i once asked ur view about ashok alco chem few days back and u said u r not tracking it .But now i read in one of the comments u said its a good stock. So mam just wana know that Did u analyse ashik alco after my comment of few days back???

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Only after that I have add Ashok Alco chem in my watch list.

      Delete
  28. Hi,
    I applied for alkem labs ipo in retail investor category for 182shares (i.e. 13 lots of 14 shares each).retail investor category subscribed 3 times.i thought i will atleast get 8 lots relativelybut i got only one lot(i.e 14 shares). why i got less.. kindly let me know the way of showing concern if anything wrong here

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry , not sure about allocation criteria of Alkem IPO

      Delete
    2. IPO allocation criteria is as below:
      When subscription is more than total no of shares to be issued bidders in retail category gets only one lot i.e if IPO is subscribed 3 times in retail category only one bidder out of 3 will get one lot.If you want to increase your chances to get more lot then you need to apply for 1 lot each in 14 different demat accounts.Hope it will help you.

      Delete
  29. Dear Mam, I have totally missed Donear? Pls suggest if I should wait for ur next stock or invest in donear? I have 4 lacs rupees?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You can buy next stock in 1 st wk of Jan. I will give some guide line to buy it on same day in the next post on 26.12. 2015.

      Delete
    2. Thank you Madam But how do we come to know about the stock?

      Delete
  30. Mam, ur view on the news abt waterbase in the today's daily ( The hindu)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have given Update on Waterbase, JK Agri and Chemfab to keep the exposure near to 10% only due to adverse effect of heavy rain. Once ponds overflown due to heavy rain than shrimp can not survive in the fields and dead shrimps will spread some infections. Hopefully condition will come well under control before next season in Q1.

      Delete
  31. Mam, whether Jayshree Chemical, Chartetered Logistic a value buy at CMP?

    ReplyDelete
  32. Mam, when you will provide Clues of next recommendation ?..if possible pls. Give on 25th....So we can try to find out in long weekend..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. First we will analyse the feedback of all blog readers than we will decide accordingly.

      Delete
  33. Hi mam,
    Thank you For devoting time to share your wisdom.
    Please give your advice on investing in gokhaldas exports.is it wise to invest in this company as a multibager.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It can give 15 -20% return per year. which is fairly good if it get compounded.

      Delete
  34. Dolly Madam,

    I came to know about your blog very recently about 1 Month Back...

    when you have given the hint related to "Donear"...Infact i have figured it out but couldn't confirm it with you as i do not know your email that time.

    Are you planning to give again such hints for the new pick that you are going to come up in January?

    Please kindly let me know...

    Thanks & Regards,
    Ravi.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Dear Madam I have 600 shares of waterbase @ 99 currently i have 14% profit in the same stock.
    If you suggest is it better to swap/switch the same with next stock which is posted on 1st week of Jan 2016 by you on blog. Waterbase can buy at lower rate because may go even lower based on the quarterly results.


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have given Update on Waterbase, JK Agri and Chemfab to keep the exposure near to 10% only due to adverse effect of heavy rain. Once ponds overflown due to heavy rain than shrimp can not survive in the fields and dead shrimps will spread some infections. Hopefully condition will come well under control before next season in Q1.

      Delete
  36. Dear friends please protest against the additional price bands. I have posted my email to bse.surv@bseindia.com. below is a copy.. if we can send 20k-50k emails daily to bse they will be forced to act. Do it today.



    Respected Exchange members,


    I would like to raise my protest in lieu of the recently announced Additional price band filters dates 2015-08-06. I have listed by concerns below:

    1) The additional price bands restrict the natural movement of the stocks, thereby increasing speculation. I have observed that stocks that reach the limit would stay locked at the price band for weeks due to artificial demand being created and punters take advantage. The day the limit increases the stocks invariably hit the circuit within seconds.

    2) In case of Take overs or open offers this rule works against the shareholders as they don't get the fair value of their purchased shares. The case of Swaraj Automobiles reflects this. Although the open offer price is above 100 and the Stock was trading at 18 Rs. when the offer was made, there is no way the price can reach close to hundred in the next 2 years if the limits remained applied. I think this is injustice to shareholders.

    3) The additional price bands have created a mental divide in the investors and most of us are now shifting to stocks that are listed on both exchanges only. I think this is against the objective of having the stocks listed on two exchanges.
    Going forward no one will be interested in stocks listed exclusively on BSE.

    4) With the new limits, a lot of share that got beaten down prior to the application of the additional price bands will never be able to recover to their original prices and investor will continue to suffer.

    In view of the above concerns, it is my humble request to the Authority to please revoke the additional price bands and help the investors.

    Regards,

    Investor

    ReplyDelete
  37. Hi Dolly Mam, Your views on Mindteck. Looks like a beneficiary of government smart cities scheme.

    Regards,
    Venu.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Dear Mam, I have some fresh money, which stock should I go for?

    ReplyDelete
  39. Replies
    1. Need to hold for 3-4 years for much better return

      Delete
  40. Hello Mam,

    Thank you for doing a wonderful job and giving us all the tips and detailed informations about the stocks which we need to buy. I thank you very much for all your analysis done.

    Mam wanted to know your views on the lubricant companies like gulf oil and tide water oil as price of crude oil would be on decline even in 2016 do you think companies like tide and gulf oil wld do well.

    Please advice mam.

    Kind Regards
    Atul

    ReplyDelete
  41. Hi Mam,
    Do you track deccan gold? They waiting for letter of intent from karnataka govt.Then they can start mining. They were waiting for mining license for last 10yrs.
    Any view.

    Regards,
    Vinay

    ReplyDelete
  42. Dear Mam, As per ur suggestion I have started to take position in Kaveri seeds around 480 lvl. Should I Buy more at current lvl or wait for more correction?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Did you check the latest update on kaveri. Monsanto has revoked their license for BT cotton seeds. Which is a big part of their revenue.
      Regards,
      Vinay

      Delete
    2. Any stock in down trend should be added in small quantities on every 5 -10% fall. Above disputed matter is in court and recently GOI has given guide lines to seed companies in this regard.

      Delete
  43. Dear Dolly Maam,

    Good day and congratulations on the blog's 1st anniversary. Many thanks for helping common investors with your value picks. I wish you all the best and healthy life and to keep continuing your services for us.

    Many thanks.
    Regards,
    Abdul Samad

    ReplyDelete
  44. Hi mam, please can you share your thoughts on L&T finance for 3 yrs time, can we expect 3-bagger,is it good candidate for investment?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry not tracking NBFC and Banking related stocks

      Delete
  45. Thanks Dolly Sir...you efforts help us very much...we are eagerly awaiting for your next pick..

    ReplyDelete
  46. Dear Dolly Mam, Your views on FIEM Industries and Lincoln Pharma for investment of 2-3 years.

    Regards,
    Venu.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry not tracking above stocks. You can keep some pharma stocks in your portfolio.

      Delete
  47. Mam I m holding 10 shares of MRF.What is your view on it ??

    ReplyDelete
  48. Hi Dolly. A humble feedback
    Your blog is excellent... its fine as is, gratitude can not be expressed in words.. I would give 10/10 to this blog. "Thanks again"

    ReplyDelete
  49. Dear mam
    Please share your view on trf and allied digital.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Hello Mam,
    First of all I wish you a happy Christmas. Wish you a happy new year too.

    Mam stocks you mentioned are superb we also learning from your fundamental report at the time of recommendation and also quarterly results report.
    I will add waterbase after this quarter results as i expect some correction due to chennai floods.
    Mam Can we have one pharma company from your side we prefer a small cap. I like suven life sciences this year it received good patents. Whats your view on this stock.
    We will be continuously reading your comments and i prefer to open all comments. however if it is against your things you can block it.

    Mam however one question which i struck from long time in my mind. Does longtime give maximum returns or short term postional calls gives greater profit.

    Thanks

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sure, I will post if I find any pharma stock with good fundamental at lower price. Most of the good pharma stocks are trading at life time high PE.

      You can hold and keep some pharma stocks in your portfolio for better return in future

      Delete
  51. ur view on patelsairtemp?

    ReplyDelete
  52. Hello Mam,

    What is your view on GTLinfra, sell or hold?

    Regards,
    Anil

    ReplyDelete
  53. Madam, A small doubt:-
    When i check PE on moneycontrol.com, say for example for lycos internet, it shows a PE of 790. Refer the link->
    http://www.moneycontrol.com/india/stockpricequote/computers-software-medium-small/lycosinternet/LGS
    whereas the screener shows a different PE. (PE of 4.17)
    https://www.screener.in/company/LYCOS/consolidated
    Madam, Pls tell me which one is correct and how to determine this. (Screener and moneycontrol gives a different TTM EPS for Lycos internet)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. BSE and NSE webs are the best for any stock statistic.

      Delete
  54. Hello madam,

    What is your view on godrej properties? how much return we can expect in 3-5 years time frame?
    I did asked you the same query in my email which I sent you along with my feedback.

    ReplyDelete
  55. Mam I have sent you mail. Plz reply.

    ReplyDelete
  56. One correction in earlier Question Accumulation lvl in kaveri seeds is 380 not 480. I have started to accumulate kaveri seed around 380 lvl. Can i add more at current lvl or wait for some more correction?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Any stock in down trend should be added in small quantities on every 5 -10% fall.

      Kaveri Seed can give better return in Q1

      Delete
  57. Madam, what is your view on Rasoya poteins Ltd ? Thanks in advance.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Hello Mam.
    Thanks for the great service provided to ordinary investors like,
    Many i guess must have benefited from this selfless service.
    God bless.

    ReplyDelete
  59. Hello Mam,
    I invested in nandan @150.could you please let me know what kind of return we can expect in next 3 years

    ReplyDelete
  60. Good morning
    How do you see the merger deal of tree house with Zee learn.53 zee learn for every 10 tree house. I am holding tree house.

    ReplyDelete
  61. Merry Xmas dolly Mam ,
    Plz advice on dr lal and Alkem lab , if acc. To you wats the best level to add these two stocks and between two who you will give more weightage .
    I added few both on listing day itself , sitting in good profit but m not a trader but now with more capital I want to add more .
    Also suggests about indigo as though I having good profit but not wanted to sell as its really nice mgmt wo survived worst .
    Thank you as always

    ReplyDelete
  62. Sorry not tracking Alkem lab and Dr Lal but in general pharma stocks can give 15 -20% return per year very easily.

    ReplyDelete
  63. the govt is not allowed to function and no reforms likely till 2017 when BJP might get majority in RS. What will happen to markets in 2016 considering this scenario. Am i justified in getting worried. thx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes it will have some effect but not that much significant. Most of the major projects and development work is right on track because it does not required any approval from opposition. Recent data shows that India's GDP growth is 7.4 % and it is better than market expectations of a 7.3 % increase, boosted by financial, real estate, Infra and manufacturing.

      Delete
  64. Mam,please share your view on Adani Ports,Emami and Reliance industries as I m holding it.

    ReplyDelete
  65. Mam
    What is your view on Ashapura intimates fashion and Tanla solutions.

    ReplyDelete
  66. Mam can you advise best pharma stocks from your view

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sure, I will post if I find any pharma stock with good fundamental at lower price.

      Delete
  67. Dear Mam, I have some money invested in Welspun Syntex. You have said its good share. But I wish to exit and invest that money in your new recommendation?
    Pls suggest if that's ok.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Money is your and decision must be taken by you.

      Delete
  68. Madam next stock will be listed on nse or bse or both?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry, as we agreed there will not be any clue.

      It is one of the best stock with very high growth potential in 2016 -17

      Delete
    2. Thanks Madam. I have a different broker for bse which doesnt give me margin. My regular broker doesnt give bse. so I have to transfer money to my bse broker upfront if its on bse so that i can buty hats why i am asking

      Delete
  69. What tgt one can expect umang dairy in 2-3 year time period.? Kwality moves a lot in recent time. Pls share your idea.

    ReplyDelete
  70. Madam ji are you holding mafatlal industries, is it right time to buy for 1-2 years holding. Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  71. I m holding pfs @ 45/- average. Your valuable suggestions on it

    ReplyDelete
  72. Hi Dollyji,
    I have around 5lacs of savings can you suggest how much should I invest and in which stock's.I cannot afford to loose money pls suggest.
    Thanks
    Anurag

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You can Invest all money if you have belief in yourself

      Delete
  73. Mam, On revival of indian economy, the capital goods company will do well, can you suggest any value buy in capital goods company?

    ReplyDelete
  74. Madam your view on Anant raj realestate

    ReplyDelete
  75. Dear Madam,
    It would be good if we try working out to guess the new stock suggestion. Otherwise it wilkl remain in UC and we can not buy it.

    Thanks,
    Tanmoy

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ok

      It is one of the best stock with highest growth potential in 2016 -17.

      Delete
  76. Hi Madam..

    Your views on National fittings @ CMP...

    Thanks,
    Vinay

    ReplyDelete
  77. Respected madam most of ur recommended stocks open in uc .how can we buy them? Is there no solution for us? Please suggest

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You can buy it by placing AMO order at market price

      Delete
  78. Happy new year to you mam what is your view on Sree rayalseema high strength hypo ltd they are the only calcium carbonate water treatment chemical manufacturers in India but the qtr results segment shows chemical with low profit margin any idea please just give your view mam it will be great help

    ReplyDelete
  79. How about Panasonic energy India

    ReplyDelete