Dear Blog Members,
We have seen that most of the comments are related to decision making for sell, hold and buy on previous suggested stocks. It gives me feeling that some of our blog members are unable to take the timely decision. Even though we have replied several time and given detailed update ‘Review of Investment Strategy’ on 6 May 2018.
In this post we have analysed data of all stocks posted from beginning of this blog to till date. We have gone through almost every type of market situation in last six years, we have seen market peak and very severe crash. It gives us fairly true data for our future strategy because sample data is large enough and spread over long period of six years.
Key Facts & Findings
- There were total 37 stock suggestion since beginning of blog in Jan 2015.
- Total 23 stocks or 62% of total suggested stocks were able to give 100% return.
- There were 7 stocks or 19 % of total suggested stocks which have given us net losses of only 30K.
- There are 7 active stocks or 19 % of total suggested stocks which have not completed yet three years.
- If someone has followed the investment strategy and booked partial profit around 100% and reinvested the amount again and again then his return on investment will be much higher then who have invested in all stocks and keeping all stocks up till now.
- The 23 stocks which were able to give 100% return, have given 23 chances to reinvest during this period.
- Pareto’ principle of 80–20 rule is applicable here because 80% of the comments are related to 7 or 20% of the losing stocks and only 20% of the comment related to 80% of winning stocks.
- It is hard fact that only 20% of the blog members are able to make decent profit or 80% of the total profit and 80% of the investors are left with merely 20% profit.
Now it is time to move forward with learning of past and try to make 100% of our blog members successful in their investment objectives. Those who want to be successful, It is time for fresh beginning. It needs to keep the things very simple just by following the below guidelines for next 12 months and have the patience to wait for 36 month. We will go for 6 to 8 stocks in this year.
1) Buying range for any stock should remain within 15% from suggested price, it gives additional flexibility of 5% from our previous range 10%. It will give chance to enter those who are late due to any reason.
2) Prefer initial allocation 10 - 15% for each stock. I will give update on it along with respective blog post, it may vary stock to stock from 10 to 15%. It gives us 5 to 8% shareholding in free of cost stocks even after taking out our initial investment by booking partial profit around 100%.
3) Must book partial profit after getting return around 90 -110 % on your investment. Keep the remaining free of cost shares for long term and reinvest principal amount again.
4) On average winning stock have given hundred percent return in 12 months but our expectation from every suggested stock is 100 % in 3 years. You can continue to hold free of cost share based on their performance for long-term five years or above for 300 to 500% return.
5) In normal condition, need to stick with our investment decision for 3 years. It means that if any non-performing stock unable to give at least 100% return in 3 years than we must take the decision to sell it and reinvest it again in some other stocks.
6) It is not advisable to buy any non-performing stock after 3 years even though it is trading within buying range. It means that any stock suggestion is valid only for 3 years, if required it will be re-suggested on blog again with modified target.
7) Investment in stock market is subjected to significant risk. Investors must be aware and ready to face it. In case of severe market crash, better to use stop-loss 30% from suggested price to limit the risk on investment.
8) If you have taken the decision to become successful investor than always be happy and never regret on any decision but learn from every right or wrong decision.
Learn from yesterday, live for today, hope for tomorrow. The important thing is not to stop questioning.
Albert Einstein
Hello Mam, Could you please advise on the company named Dlink India?? I believe that it will be a major player in digital India theme...Its a sincere request that even if you are not tracking still if you could look at it and suggest me please..Your old follower...
ReplyDeleteD-Link is market leader in networking and surveillance product in India. But I am not tracking this company closely.
DeleteThank you so much mam for your reply..So would it be precise to say that I can look to invest in this company as it's a market leader in its products and India is moving towards digital theme??
DeleteGod bless you mam...
ReplyDeleteNo words to express happiness of feelings that you are spending your quality time of life for us... ONLY GOD CAN DO IT AND YOU ARE GOD FOR US.
thank you once again and take care.
Learn from yesterday, live for today, hope for tomorrow. The important thing is not to stop questioning.
ReplyDeleteVery important to implement...i live and always try to follow Albert Einstein...
DEAR MAM thanks for your guidance
ReplyDeletethanks a lot Mam for the detailed update, it really helps to boost the confidence! 🙏
ReplyDeleteMadam, your valuable suggestion on "GRRENPANAEL" industries for longterm view. Thank you
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it
DeleteThank you ma'mm for your valuable guidance, sharing a new investment strategy, encouragement and new hope for the upcomming future.
ReplyDeleteHello Mam
ReplyDeleteThanks for your deep dive analysis of past perfomance. For me personally your answers to questions raised by blog members is my education in stock Investment. Thanks for the patience, guidance and attention you give to all of us.
Regards
Sunil Paulose
Madam, mera purchase price of Omkar @176, sell nahi karpaya demerger listing ke time pe, is rally mein mera purchase price milsakte hain ya nahi (Omkar+Lasa), ye free of cost shares nahi.
ReplyDeleteYou can sell Omkar and Lasa shares on rise and reinvest it again in other stock. It is not about profit or loss but management has lost the trust of investors. they have ruined their own business for their personal gain and family feud
Deletecan you please mark the lasa and omkar as sell in the excel sheet please.
Deletethanks a lot
Thank you so much Madam! Huge respect for the selfless support you are extending to the small scale investor community through this platform. I express my sincere gratitude for the time and effort you spare towards supporting us! May God bless you and your family abundantly!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much Madam! Huge respect for the selfless support you are extending to the small scale investor community through this platform. I express my sincere gratitude for the time and effort you spare towards supporting us! May God bless you and your family abundantly!
ReplyDeleteThank a lot for the clear guidance.
ReplyDeleteAs per rule no 3 at 100% we book profit and keep the remaining stock, but when should we book profit again. Like deepak nitrite which goes above 300%, shall we book some profit again or leave the remaning stock as it is? Need your guidence pls considering a small investor with 20K to 40K invested on each stock.
These 5 to 8% free of cost share are the real investment which can give huge gain in the long run. You can keep the growing and well performing companies for life time. Same time you can concentrate your portfolio by selling the non-performing free of cost stocks as per guidelines given above. In this case you can wait for longer period 5 years and above. Generally we are going for micro and small cap stocks if any stock will able to move in the category of mid-cap or large cap then gain will be huge and unimaginable. rest hundred percent gain is very much achievable and it is very small return.
DeleteGreetings of the day Respected madam,
ReplyDeleteMam you have clearly mentioned which stock's to hold and exit, but sorry IAM still asking this question,
I was holding pennar industry @ 60 before your recommendation, and in December 2020,bought @ 16, so my average price has come down to 40, Can I hold it or exit.
Thanks and regards madam.
It may go above 60 or below 30 but we have already given reasonable time of three-years and it has not performed so it is time to take the decision. We should love our hard earned money not the stock, love for stock only until it is performing well and giving reasonable return.
DeleteMam, with your blessings i was able to take risk and give highest allocation to dnl...
ReplyDeleteIt has given multifold return as well but God wanted me to go through tough period of life and so bma wealth creator, my broker with whom i held every stock of dnl declared as defaulter and now the claim is being settled at buy price... Very unfortunate to my entire family.
But your presence has always been bringing confidence back to me for investing and not to leave until i succeed, succeed as per my defination...
Hence beginning journey of investing once again from scratch with whatever i am left with, in fact nse has not yet deposited claim amount yet but hoping to get it soon.
I am not going to leave it like this for my life and hence have strong belief that deepak fertilizer will give me similar return as that of dnl in next 2 years..
Just need your thought if i can make fresh investment at cmp...
God bless you. I am left with very less amount for fresh investment but i am sure, with you, i will succeed...
It is really sad that your broker has cheated innocent investors. God may have better plan for you.
DeleteDeepak fertilisers is also having similar or more potential then DNL, it will take 2-3 years time to retire its debt. Company is trying to sell its pune land if it will happen then it may give much better return than expected time.
Dear blog members
Always go for financially strong brokers with banking facility like SBI, ICICIDirect or HDFC. their brokerage cost maybe little high but it will give you peace of mind because we are not daily trader we invest once or twice in month. For daily trading you can keep separate low-cost brokerage or or zero brokerage account.
Your presence in our life is much precious than my return on investment...
DeleteLike i mentioned many times earlier, you are God for me and with you i will definitely succeed...
Take care
Mam when is next stock post
ReplyDeleteMost probably will go for next stock before end of this month
DeleteMadam deepak fertilizer shown an excellent performance for the last 1 year and have bright future, but stock is not moving much, can we expect a good move in the coming quarters, what is ur opinion on Tata Teleservices(maharashtra) and Tejas Network Thanks
ReplyDeleteDeepak fertilisers will also move up in coming quarters and it will continue to give good result and good dividend in future.
DeleteSorry not tracking other stocks
Mam,Thanks for your consolidated statement of all the suggested stocks, I have Nitinspinners@60 and Gati@75 average price, Do I need to exit these stocks or can hold for sometime for 100% returns?
ReplyDeleteHere everyone have bought both stock above hundred rupees and we have already given reasonable time of three-years and it has not performed so it is time to take the decision. We should love our hard earned money not the stock, love for stock only until it is performing well and giving reasonable return. we are not going to keep the fund idle but we are going to invest in other opportunity with possibility of better and faster return.
DeleteMa'am,
ReplyDeleteThank you very much for guiding us, very important guidelines in investing.
Maam when shall you give us the next stock idea.
Most probably will go for next stock before end of this month
DeleteMadam please suggest any Electric vehicle stock for next 10 years and green energy stocks like Adani green. Thank you.
ReplyDeletesure I will suggested if I find something similar.
DeleteSir any reason for not mentioning buy or add in the above image - while u have mentioned hold and sell ?
ReplyDeleteAny stock can be bought within three years and within 15% from suggested price. Out of seven stock mentioned under hold, some stocks are trading well above 15% and some stocks are left with few months. If any stocks left with at least one year or above and still trading within buying range then definitely it can be bought.
DeleteDear Maam, Thanks so much for detailed update. Please suggest next stock which can give return like Deepak Nitrate. May god bless you and your family.
ReplyDeleteIn the long run there are several companies which can scale their business much bigger from present level like Deepak fertiliser, ABFRL, ADF foods, jubilant industry, JK agri, Kamdhenu, Shree Pushkar, Talbros autos, TCI express, orient electric, Insecticide etc
DeleteMadam,As per the price chart shall we understand it as EXITING all the stocks ie. KCP,NITIN SPINNERS,SINTEX, KESORAM and reinvest else where. as these are 60% of my port folio and if i were to exit them at current price i shall loose 40% of my capital in these 5 alone.kindly advice if i shall move out of them and reinvest my remaining 20% capital or continue to hold them to exit near cost. please advice.
ReplyDeleteyou can gradually exit these stocks in positive market trend at higher level.
DeleteMadam, please share your view on TATA ELAXI for long term. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it
DeleteThank you madam, I am holding many stocks as I did not sell, which of these should we sell and which ones should we keep? Thanks a lot
ReplyDeleteyou can continue to hold all stocks which have given hundred percent return and hold them in future if they continue to deliver good return
DeleteMam,Thanks for update & clear suggestion.Hoping your exit suggestion is not on immediate basis,it may be near to suggested price or with a small gain.kindly inform.
ReplyDeletedefinitely if any stock not performing for three years then we should start thinking on it and looking for best the possible chance to exit and reinvest it again.
DeleteMadam,
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot for detailed analysis.
HOW about NOCIl ? I didnt saw that stock in detailed report .
Could please share your view about it ?
We cover only those stocks which are posted on the blog
DeleteNocil is good stock you can continue to hold it, if you want to buy it then wait for some correction
DeleteMadam, thanks for your advise and feedback. Mam, i am recent followers and entered Ganesh Housing@31 RS last month,Can I expect 100% returns in 1 to 3 year for this stock?
ReplyDeleteYou can continue to hold but we stop tracking non-performing stock after monitoring it for three years on the blog
DeleteMadam Kamdhenu demerger still is pending can we hold ? Also please mention madam those stock can be buy @ current level in this stocks
ReplyDeleteYes you can continue to hold free of cost kamdhenu share even for much longer period.
DeleteAny stock can be bought within three years and within 15% from suggested price. Out of seven stock mentioned under hold, some stocks are trading well above 15% and some stocks are left with few months. If any stocks left with at least one year or above and still trading within buying range then definitely it can be bought.
Next stock will be posted before end of this month
Madam, please suggest my purchase price of Amarjyoti spinners @136, short term view before budget. Or if I hold for longterm can I get good returns in near future.
ReplyDeleteyou can continue to hold it for long term but textile sector will take few more quarters to come out from slump
DeleteMadam your views on NOCIL and sequent scientific at CMP. Thanks
ReplyDelete
DeleteNocil is good stock you can continue to hold it, if you want to buy it then wait for some correction but not tracking other stock
Hello Mam, Thank you for your response to D-Link India..So would it be precise to say that I can invest in the company at present valuation?? As it is the leader in its products in India and also the digital theme will gain momentum in future??
ReplyDeleteI am not tracking this stock so I cannot give any comment on it.
DeleteMam your view on khadim india, srikalahasti pipes and quickheal tech?
ReplyDeleteSiri pipe is good stock but there is some concern about its management because last time they have used fund of this company for other group companies. not tracking other stocks
DeleteDear Ma'am
DeleteMany thanks for your priceless advices. wish you good health, peace and happiness.
I wish to know how you gather the information like "Siri pipe management have used fund of this company for other group companies"
Thanks for the detail review of all stocks. This will really help and boost confidence amongst the blog members. I have got a couple of queries.
ReplyDelete1) Holding Gati since your recommendation. Should I continue to hold or exit now?
2) Is it advisable to buy Bharat Gears at cmp?
3) I'm holding Orient Electric since demerger time. Should I book profit and reinvest to other stock?
4) Can we buy Sunflag at cmp?
5)Your view on Sintex plastic please.
Thanks again!
definitely if any stock not performing for three years then we should start thinking on it and looking for best the possible chance to exit and reinvest it again.
DeleteAny stock can be bought within three years and within 15% from suggested price. Out of seven stock mentioned under hold, some stocks are trading well above 15% and some stocks are left with few months. If any stocks left with at least one year or above and still trading within buying range then definitely it can be bought.
you can continue to hold free of cost shares of orient electric for long-term
Thanks ma’am for the detailed update. Eagerly waiting for your next blaster!!
ReplyDeleteNext stock will be posted in the last week of this month
DeleteHello Mam, Thanks for your detailed update, very much appreciated. It gives lot of insight to me.
ReplyDeletePlease let me know any specific reason for your recommendation to hold Ganesh Housing stock though the current value has fallen to near 25% of the suggested price and the investment period has come to near three years.
Stocks which are kept under hold, have not yet completed three years.
DeleteIf any stock not performing for three years then we should start thinking on it and looking for best the possible chance to exit and reinvest it again.
Maam I have all the stocks which u mentioned as exit but they r averaged much lower with assumption that fundamentally they r strong. E.g. nitin kesoram. So in this case is it recommended to exit or one can hold and see the upmove. Like in case of nitin stock has actually bounced back well from lows. Although not reached the buy price. Can u comment maam. If i wish to hold kesoram. Nitin gulf petro. Can i hold or exit is proposed
ReplyDeleteHere everyone have bought these stocks almost at similar price and we have already given reasonable time of three-years and these stocks have not performed so it is time to take the decision. We should love our hard earned money not the stock, love for stock only until it is performing well and giving reasonable return. we are not going to keep the fund idle but we are going to invest in other opportunity with possibility of better and faster return.
DeleteMadam, DTIL book value showing 1100+ but stock is not moving, suggest accordingly suitable action to Hold or sell. Thank you
ReplyDeletethose stocks which have already given hundred percent return, you can continue to hold free of cost shares for long-term.
DeleteMadam, please suggest your view on Shree Pustakar, it is already 4 years completed. now is it on your tracking list or not and what we have to do hold or sell.
ReplyDeleteyou can continue to hold free of cost share for long term. It will give good return in future
DeleteDear Madam, Thank you very much for your valuable feedback on the performance of the stock posted in your blog. God bless you and your family for your selfless service to the small retail investors and society.
ReplyDeleteYour inputs on Nucleus Software Exports Ltd and Mold-Tek Packaging Ltd. Thanks in advance!
both are good stock, if you already invested then you can continue to hold but not advisable to buy at these levels
DeleteDolly Mam,
ReplyDeleteThanks for the wonderful association with this blog since 2015. I have been following your tips and had invested 4 lacs and it grew to 12lacs. Made the stocks free of cost and put the initial capital in MF in monthly Dividend scheme. This way am getting fixed income monthly. Remember all you have to grow money from your existing capital.
Follow Dolly Mam's tips and you all will be in good profit.
Dear Madam,
ReplyDelete1. Shall we book partial profit on stock even if our initial investment is 10% or less?
2. What shall we do for a stock which is trading less than 100% profit now, not booked profit earlier at 100%(eg ABFRL) and already completed 3 years
generally we invest in micro or small cap stocks, price fluctuation in these stocks is high so it is always good to book the profit around hundred percent and keep the remaining free of cost share for long-term capital application. it will give you opportunity for re-investing principal amount again and again without any fresh infusion of fund.
Delete10% allocation in single stock is fair enough for balanced portfolio. if someone have 5% free of cost share for 10 -15 stock then it will give very stable portfolio for any kind of market situation.
Thanks mam of the update on all stocks suggested by you. Could you share your views on Astral poly Tec,thanks in advance.
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it
DeleteHi Mam,
ReplyDeleteI have following stocks but not sure what should I do, need your guidance.
Rain 250 @ 120 = +11%
Panama 200 @ 112 = -17%
Nocil 51 @ 87 = +61%
Kamdhenu 50 @ 52 = +150%
Atul auto 50 @ 150 = +15%
Everest ind 48 @ 210 = +45%
FSL 60 @ 45 = +100% (This is free stocks as half of them at 112)
you can continue to hold all stocks as it is
DeleteDear madam, please cover one stock from pharma sector if possible
ReplyDeleteWe will try to cover pharma sector in coming months
DeleteMam your view on andhra sugar
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it
DeleteDear all blog members, please take below note by mam VERY SERIOUSLY, because i am still suffering due to this mistake and i really don't want anyone of us to go through my situation... Please take it seriously
ReplyDelete"Always go for financially strong brokers with banking facility like SBI, ICICIDirect or HDFC. their brokerage cost maybe little high but it will give you peace of mind because we are not daily trader we invest once or twice in month. For daily trading you can keep separate low-cost brokerage or or zero brokerage account"
Can you clearly explain what happened to you, I thought that once we buy the stock which are deposited in our NSDL account and even if any brokerage bankrupt the NSDL is responsible for it.
DeleteSuppose I have sharekhan account and if this brokerage bankrupt then all of my stocks will be in danger? NSDL is nor responsible? can not we sell the stocks from any other brokerage account?
Is abfrl still capable of being a lare cap company in next 7 years. Can we hold abfrl shares for long team or reinvest in other shares.
ReplyDeleteYes it has a lot of potential to grow in the long run
DeleteMadam,I purchased rain industries share 5000 at145/-a piece .kindly inform the the present status ofvertical soft tech plant,ACP plant being constructed at Vizag SEZ and the availability of raw material to the said green field plant in contest of restrictions on import of GPC by the Hon SC.kindly explain in detail
ReplyDeleteIts capacity utilisation will improve in coming quarters and benefit of advanced materials, product diversification will start reflecting from next FY
DeleteMadam, we are very thank full to regular update of our blog. Please suggest a u coming IT stock like TCS/ INFOSYS for next 10 years. thank you.
ReplyDeleteI think Oracle financial services is good company in IT space to invest
DeleteSure if we find any good opportunity then definitely will go for it
DeleteIt is a good stock but too expensive, what will be the right price to enter it.
DeleteMadam, DTIL book value showing Rs. 1179 after sold their tea brand of Lal goda Kala goda but why the stock is not moving in upside, recently somewhere I road management is planning to sell their tea field near Kolkatta. Stock was suggested on March 2015. I didn't book any partial profits on this scrip. Stock has completed around 6 years after your suggestion. now is it in tracking list?. Now what I have to do hold or sell please suggest accordingly. Thank you
ReplyDeleteDue to same reason generally we insist to book the partial profit around hundred percent, it will give peace of mind whether stock is moving or not moving.
DeleteIt will move up in coming quarters then you can book partial profit and keep on the free of cost share for long-term.
Madam please suggest your views on HAPPIEST MINDS future prospects. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it
DeleteSir, once stock achieve 100% return we should book how much profit.i mean apart from principal amount how much more should we take out and keep the rest for long term
ReplyDeleteIf you able to take out your principal amount then remaining shares are your profit. You have the both option if free of cost stocks are performing well then you can continue to hold for long-term otherwise you can sell and use the fund for your personal expenses and enjoy
DeleteGood evening madam, thanks to you for your support. I have sent you mail of my holding. If gets time plz reply me on my holding.
ReplyDeleteI have Raymond & Monte Carlo in my portfolio. can I hold for long term or exit now.
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking any of these stocks
DeleteMadam,I Purchased 10000shares of Mamappuram finance in 2019The stock is not moving towards north despite good results.Will you please explain the future of the share.Thanking you
ReplyDeletemost of the NBFC stocks have recovered to pre Covid-19 level and Manappuram finance is also trading near to that level. It will also move along with others once complete sector will start performing.
DeleteHello Mam, pls share your views on Vinyal chemicals,as Pidilite holds 40% stake will it be right to invest and forget.Thanks in advance.
ReplyDeleteSorry not tracking it
DeleteRespected Rajiv sir, please share your view on Caplin point lab for investment purpose.
ReplyDeleteIn general pharma and chemicals sector will do very well in future but not tracking this stocks
DeleteMadam..your views on paragmilk? I invested at 93 six months back. Can it give 100% return in next 6 months
ReplyDeleteGood morning madam, I bought IDFC before demerger @120/- 6/7 years ago, after demerger IDFC & IDFC first bank now both stocks are start their upward journey. Please suggest me can I book my investment amount or wait for IDFC first bank progress. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteIDFC first bank is young and have a lot of growth possibilities in the long run. You can continue to hold it. Not tracking other stock
DeleteDear mam can you please advise how much more time we have to hold GP PETROLEUM to get 100% profit from suggested price. Thank in advance
ReplyDeleteThe stocks which are kept under hold have not yet completed three years. GP petroleum is completing its three-year of suggestion in May 2021.
DeleteIf any stock not performing for three years then we should start thinking on it and looking for best the possible chance to exit and reinvest it again.
Can i invest in Aditya Birla Fashion now. Todays price is 152.
ReplyDeleteTextiles sector is still suppressed under the impact of Covid 19 it may take few more quarter to recover fully. The stock has already passed three years so better to invest in recent stocks.
DeleteHi Madam, I will greatful if you can give your views on ITC, Godrej Consumer, city union bank, L&T Finance holdings, Mahindra and Mahindra Financial Services stock
ReplyDeleteDear Ma'am
ReplyDeleteI wish to know the following please.
1. How you find the these good stocks and the best entry price level.
2. How you analise the sincereness of management of the company.
3. Could you share please the stocks you are tracking.
I wish to repeat the wards of previous blogger....
No words to express happiness of feelings that you are spending your quality time of life for us... ONLY GOD CAN DO IT AND YOU ARE GOD FOR US.
thank you once again and take care Ma'am.
Thank u mam
ReplyDelete